time-nuts@lists.febo.com

Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement

View all threads

Re: [time-nuts] eBay GPS antenna test results.

JG
John Green
Fri, Feb 9, 2018 9:43 PM

To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt design,
it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power supply
and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull
current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I continued
to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly
dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA
and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to
130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I reached
12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current
limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it,
waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well
with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my
12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if
it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a
bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact the
seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will
get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about
experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the lesson
after. Oh well.

To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt design, it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power supply and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I continued to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to 130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I reached 12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it, waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my 12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact the seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the lesson after. Oh well.
BK
Bob kb8tq
Fri, Feb 9, 2018 10:37 PM

Hi

Is it labeled 3.3 to 18V on the antenna?

Bob

On Feb 9, 2018, at 4:43 PM, John Green wpxs472@gmail.com wrote:

To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt design,
it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power supply
and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull
current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I continued
to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly
dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA
and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to
130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I reached
12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current
limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it,
waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well
with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my
12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if
it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a
bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact the
seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will
get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about
experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the lesson
after. Oh well.


time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
and follow the instructions there.

Hi Is it labeled 3.3 to 18V on the antenna? Bob > On Feb 9, 2018, at 4:43 PM, John Green <wpxs472@gmail.com> wrote: > > To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt design, > it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power supply > and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull > current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I continued > to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly > dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA > and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to > 130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I reached > 12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current > limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it, > waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well > with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my > 12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if > it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a > bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact the > seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will > get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about > experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the lesson > after. Oh well. > _______________________________________________ > time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com > To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts > and follow the instructions there.
DD
Dr. David Kirkby
Fri, Feb 9, 2018 11:00 PM

On 9 February 2018 at 21:43, John Green wpxs472@gmail.com wrote:

To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt design,
it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power supply
and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull
current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I continued
to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly
dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA
and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to
130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I reached
12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current
limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it,
waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well
with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my
12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if
it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a
bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact the
seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will
get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about
experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the lesson
after. Oh well.

You should not open it up, but open an eBay case for item not as described.
If it said it would do 3-18 V, but does not, then its not as described, and
you should get your money back. The chances are the seller will not want to
arrange collection, so you will probably get to keep it anyway. But you
should get a refund before opening it up.

Dave

On 9 February 2018 at 21:43, John Green <wpxs472@gmail.com> wrote: > To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt design, > it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power supply > and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull > current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I continued > to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly > dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA > and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to > 130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I reached > 12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current > limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it, > waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well > with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my > 12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if > it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a > bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact the > seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will > get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about > experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the lesson > after. Oh well. > You should not open it up, but open an eBay case for item not as described. If it said it would do 3-18 V, but does not, then its not as described, and you should get your money back. The chances are the seller will not want to arrange collection, so you will probably get to keep it anyway. But you should get a refund before opening it up. Dave
DW
Dana Whitlow
Sat, Feb 10, 2018 12:37 AM

I would surmise that the antenna has (or rather had) a protection network
to protect against voltage spikes or surges.  Your description of events
seems consistent with an triggered SCR crowbar circuit, and the 2nd
attempt at the higher current limit shorted the SCR.  Note that this may
not have been a regular SCR, but perhaps a NPN/PNP pair hooked up
to emulate an SCR.  If you can find evidence of such a circuit, it may
be replaceable or simply removable, leaving the antenna fully functional.

Assuming this works, do keep the supply voltage down to something
reasonable like 5 or 6 volts.  Excess voltage will result in unneeded
heat generation in whatever regulator the antenna uses, shortening
its life.

Dana

On Fri, Feb 9, 2018 at 5:00 PM, Dr. David Kirkby <
drkirkby@kirkbymicrowave.co.uk> wrote:

On 9 February 2018 at 21:43, John Green wpxs472@gmail.com wrote:

To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt

design,

it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power

supply

and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull
current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I

continued

to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly
dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA
and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to
130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I

reached

12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current
limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it,
waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well
with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my
12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if
it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a
bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact

the

seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will
get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about
experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the

lesson

after. Oh well.

You should not open it up, but open an eBay case for item not as described.
If it said it would do 3-18 V, but does not, then its not as described, and
you should get your money back. The chances are the seller will not want to
arrange collection, so you will probably get to keep it anyway. But you
should get a refund before opening it up.

Dave


time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/
mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
and follow the instructions there.

I would surmise that the antenna has (or rather had) a protection network to protect against voltage spikes or surges. Your description of events seems consistent with an triggered SCR crowbar circuit, and the 2nd attempt at the higher current limit shorted the SCR. Note that this may not have been a regular SCR, but perhaps a NPN/PNP pair hooked up to emulate an SCR. If you can find evidence of such a circuit, it may be replaceable or simply removable, leaving the antenna fully functional. Assuming this works, do keep the supply voltage down to something reasonable like 5 or 6 volts. Excess voltage will result in unneeded heat generation in whatever regulator the antenna uses, shortening its life. Dana On Fri, Feb 9, 2018 at 5:00 PM, Dr. David Kirkby < drkirkby@kirkbymicrowave.co.uk> wrote: > On 9 February 2018 at 21:43, John Green <wpxs472@gmail.com> wrote: > > > To those who doubted that the antenna was actually a 3.3 to 18 volt > design, > > it seems you were correct. Today, I hooked it up to a variable power > supply > > and slowly raised the DC voltage fed to the antenna. It began to pull > > current at about 2.9 volts and at 3.3 volts, took about 40 mA. I > continued > > to slowly raise the voltage. At about 7.5 volts, the current suddenly > > dropped to 10 mA. At just below 12 volts, it suddenly increased to 80 mA > > and the supply went into current limit. I increased the current limit to > > 130 mA and repeated the exercise. Everything went as above until I > reached > > 12 volts and the current went to 130 mA and the supply went into current > > limit. Lowering the voltage didn't lower the current. I disconnected it, > > waited a minute, and tried again. Yep, shorted. It would have worked well > > with the T bolt, but would have blown anyway if I tried to use it with my > > 12 volt supply and bias T. I guess I will get inside it somehow to see if > > it can be repaired. My first attempt ended in failure. I guess I need a > > bigger screwdriver with which to pry the top off. I am going to contact > the > > seller and tell them it was not as advertised. I kind of doubt that will > > get me anything, but it won't hurt to try. There is a saying about > > experience being a cruel teacher. You get the results first, and the > lesson > > after. Oh well. > > > > > You should not open it up, but open an eBay case for item not as described. > If it said it would do 3-18 V, but does not, then its not as described, and > you should get your money back. The chances are the seller will not want to > arrange collection, so you will probably get to keep it anyway. But you > should get a refund before opening it up. > > Dave > _______________________________________________ > time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com > To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/ > mailman/listinfo/time-nuts > and follow the instructions there. >