I would suggest that if you are looking at taking temperature sensor data
and attempting to control some type of heating/cooling device that you
implement a PID loop for stability.
https://www.crossco.com/blog/basics-tuning-pid-loops
Many simplistic approaches use an ON-OFF controller to turn on cooling or
heaters. These can make your stability problems worse than if you just
wrapped things up in an insulating blanket. You end up cycling from one
extreme to the next.
PID loops when properly tuned will vary the speed, current or duty cycle as
the temperature approaches a set-point. This avoids overshoot and gives
much finer control over the temperature.
We used to use 4 wire platinum probes to measure temperature down to the
hundredth of a degree. Then for control of the heater element we had a PWM
(pulse width modulated) supply. Once the loop was tuned (to minimize
positive feedback that causes increasingly crazy oscillations in
temperature while at the same time settling in once the temperature soaked
through the mass) we could hold a set-point through some wild external
temperature extremes.
There are software implementations of PID (Proportional, Integral,
Derivative) that are pretty easy to understand. There are also surplus
temperature controllers on eBay that can accomplish the same thing.
Ms. Tisha Hayes, AA4HA
I will comment on a couple postings:
On Wed, Apr 4, 2018 at 8:00 PM, Tisha Hayes tisha.hayes@gmail.com wrote:
I would suggest that if you are looking at taking temperature sensor data
and attempting to control some type of heating/cooling device that you
implement a PID loop for stability.
I have implemented a PID controller with PWM output for a Peltier Cooler
for what is basically an oven to test TCXO boards. Performance is pretty
good, holding the temperature to within tenths of a degree.
I tend to connect sensors or sensor boards to an Arduino and output data to
and take commands from the serial port. The Arduino does the "real time"
stuff and the fancier stuff is implemented on a PC.
On Thu, Apr 5, 2018 at 6:20 AM, Bob kb8tq kb8tq@n1k.org wrote:
Hi
If you want something that is pre-calibrated, then the IC based parts are
the way to go.
I have used thermocouples with MAX31855 thermocouple interface boards and
also have used DS18B20s, which are quite interesting "IC" parts. You can
connect several in parallel, and they use the "One Wire" protocol, easy to
implement, saving wires. The problem with them is there are lots of
counterfeits out there. I bought them from a random supplier and they did
not work correctly. I contacted the manufacturer and they confirmed they
never made any with the date code that was printed on them. I bought some
from Digikey and they looked different and worked fine. Luckily I was able
to return the bad ones.
Regards,
Mark
W7MLG